🍿 Watch Picker
Watchlist

Best on Prime Video / Mystery

The best mystery shows and movies on Prime Video

The highest-rated mystery titles streaming on Prime Video right now, ranked by Trust Score.

Your services:
NHuluPrimeD+TV+MaxPeacock
Dexter
1
Prime

Dexter

94Trust
2006·8 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Usual Suspects
2
PrimeMax

The Usual Suspects

93Trust
1995·1h 41mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Memento
3
NHuluPrimePeacock

Memento

92Trust
2000·1h 48mmovieR
MysteryThriller
L.A. Confidential
4
Prime

L.A. Confidential

90Trust
1997·2h 12mmovieR
CrimeMystery
The Thing
5
Prime

The Thing

90Trust
1982·1h 42mmovieR
HorrorMysteryScience Fiction
Criminal Minds
6
HuluPrime

Criminal Minds

88Trust
2005·19 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Donnie Darko
7
HuluPrimePeacock

Donnie Darko

88Trust
2001·1h 48mmovieR
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
The Expanse
8
Prime

The Expanse

88Trust
2015·6 seasonstvTV-14
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
Bones
9
HuluPrimePeacock

Bones

87Trust
2005·12 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Taboo
10
PrimePeacock

Taboo

87Trust
2017·1 seasontvTV-14
DramaMysteryThriller
The Night Manager
11
Prime

The Night Manager

87Trust
2016·2 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
12
Prime

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

87Trust
2009·2h 26mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
The Man from Earth
13
Prime

The Man from Earth

87Trust
2007·1h 27mmovie
DramaFantasyMystery
Bates Motel
14
Prime

Bates Motel

86Trust
2013·5 seasonstvTV-14
DramaHorrorMystery
Desperate Housewives
15
HuluPrime

Desperate Housewives

86Trust
2004·8 seasonstvTV-PG
ComedyDramaMystery
The Lincoln Lawyer
16
NPrime

The Lincoln Lawyer

86Trust
2022·4 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Psych
17
PrimePeacock

Psych

85Trust
2006·8 seasonstvTV-PG
ComedyCrimeMystery
Upload
18
HuluPrime

Upload

85Trust
2020·4 seasonstvTV-MA
ComedyMysteryScience Fiction
Yellowjackets
19
NPrime

Yellowjackets

85Trust
2021·4 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaHorrorMystery
The Sheep Detectives
20
Prime

The Sheep Detectives

85Trust
2026·1h 54mmoviePG
ComedyFamilyMystery
Line of Duty
21
PrimePeacock

Line of Duty

84Trust
2012·7 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Blow Out
22
Prime

Blow Out

84Trust
1981·1h 41mmovieR
CrimeMystery
Disconnect
23
NPrime

Disconnect

84Trust
2013·1h 55mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Charmed
24
PrimePeacock

Charmed

83Trust
1998·8 seasonstvTV-14
DramaFantasyMystery
Now You See Me
25
Prime

Now You See Me

83Trust
2013·1h 55mmoviePG-13
CrimeMysteryThriller
Blue Bloods
26
Prime

Blue Bloods

82Trust
2010·14 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
The Capture
27
PrimePeacock

The Capture

81Trust
2019·3 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The X-Files
28
Prime

The X-Files

81Trust
1998·2h 1mmoviePG-13
AdventureMystery
Triangle
29
PrimePeacock

Triangle

81Trust
2009·1h 38mmovieR
FantasyMysteryScience Fiction
Hunters
30
NPrime

Hunters

80Trust
2020·2 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Shetland
31
Prime

Shetland

80Trust
2013·11 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Limey
32
Prime

The Limey

80Trust
1999·1h 28mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Outer Range
33
Prime

Outer Range

79Trust
2022·2 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaMysteryThriller
Perception
34
Prime

Perception

79Trust
2012·3 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Unforgettable
35
Prime

Unforgettable

78Trust
2011·4 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
We Were Liars
36
Prime

We Were Liars

78Trust
2025·1 seasontvTV-14
DramaMysteryRomance
Oculus
37
NPrime

Oculus

78Trust
2014·1h 44mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Saint Maud
38
Prime

Saint Maud

78Trust
2020·1h 24mmovieR
HorrorMystery
56 Days
39
Prime

56 Days

77Trust
2026·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Endless
40
PrimePeacock

The Endless

77Trust
2017·1h 51mmovie
HorrorMysteryScience Fiction

Showing 40 of 61