🍿 Watch Picker
Watchlist

Best on Apple TV+ / Mystery

The best mystery shows and movies on Apple TV+

The highest-rated mystery titles streaming on Apple TV+ right now, ranked by Trust Score.

Your services:
NHuluPrimeD+TV+MaxPeacock
Severance
1
TV+

Severance

92Trust
2022·3 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
A Beautiful Mind
2
TV+

A Beautiful Mind

90Trust
2001·2h 15mmoviePG-13
DramaMystery
Silo
3
TV+

Silo

90Trust
2023·4 seasonstvTV-MA
AdventureDramaMystery
The Sixth Sense
4
Leaving Oct 1
TV+Peacock

The Sixth Sense

90Trust
1999·1h 47mmoviePG-13
DramaMysteryThriller
Presumed Innocent
5
TV+

Presumed Innocent

86Trust
2024·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Defending Jacob
6
TV+

Defending Jacob

85Trust
2020·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Disclaimer
7
TV+

Disclaimer

83Trust
2024·1 seasontvTV-MA
DramaMysteryThriller
Servant
8
TV+

Servant

83Trust
2019·4 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaHorrorMystery
I, Robot
9
TV+

I, Robot

82Trust
2004·1h 54mmoviePG-13
ActionMysteryScience Fiction
The Tragedy of Macbeth
10
TV+

The Tragedy of Macbeth

82Trust
2021·1h 45mmovieR
DramaMysteryThriller
Shining Girls
11
TV+

Shining Girls

80Trust
2022·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Afterparty
12
TV+

The Afterparty

80Trust
2022·2 seasonstvTV-MA
ComedyCrimeMystery
Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed
13
TV+

Maximum Pleasure Guaranteed

79Trust
2026·1 seasontvTV-MA
ComedyMystery
Truth Be Told
14
TV+

Truth Be Told

79Trust
2019·3 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Home Before Dark
15
TV+

Home Before Dark

77Trust
2020·2 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Last Seen
16
TV+

Last Seen

76Trust
2026·1 seasontvTV-MA
MysteryThriller
The Last Thing He Told Me
17
TV+

The Last Thing He Told Me

75Trust
2023·2 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaMysteryThriller
Sunny
18
TV+

Sunny

74Trust
2024·1 seasontvTV-MA
ComedyDramaMystery
Smoke
19
TV+

Smoke

73Trust
2025·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Big Door Prize
20
TV+

The Big Door Prize

73Trust
2023·2 seasonstvTV-MA
ComedyMystery
Dr. Brain
21
TV+

Dr. Brain

72Trust
2021·1 seasontvTV-MA
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
Suspicion
22
TV+

Suspicion

72Trust
2022·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Essex Serpent
23
TV+

The Essex Serpent

72Trust
2022·1 seasontvTV-14
DramaFantasyMystery
Extrapolations
24
TV+

Extrapolations

70Trust
2023·1 seasontvTV-MA
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
Lady in the Lake
25
TV+

Lady in the Lake

70Trust
2024·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Women in Blue
26
TV+

Women in Blue

70Trust
2024·2 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Ghostwriter
27
TV+

Ghostwriter

67Trust
2019·3 seasonstvTV-G
FamilyFantasyMystery
Highest 2 Lowest
28
TV+

Highest 2 Lowest

66Trust
2025·2h 13mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery