Watch Picker
Watchlist

Best on Paramount+ / Mystery

The best mystery shows and movies on Paramount+

The highest-rated mystery titles streaming on Paramount+ right now, ranked by Trust Score.

Your services:

Se7en
1
P+

Se7en

96Trust
1995·2h 6mmovieR
CrimeMystery
Dexter
2
PrimeP+

Dexter

95Trust
2006·8 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Dexter: Resurrection
3
New season Nov 1
PrimeP+

Dexter: Resurrection

91Trust
2025·2 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Blade Runner 2049
4
Leaving Nov 1
PrimeP+

Blade Runner 2049

91Trust
2017·2h 43mmovieR
ActionDramaMystery
Arrival
5
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Arrival

91Trust
2016·1h 56mmoviePG-13
DramaMysteryScience Fiction
Primal Fear
6
P+

Primal Fear

90Trust
1996·2h 10mmovie
CrimeDramaMystery
Criminal Minds
7
HuluPrimePeacockP+

Criminal Minds

89Trust
2005·19 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Dexter: New Blood
8
PrimeP+

Dexter: New Blood

89Trust
2021·1 seasontv
CrimeDramaMystery
Zodiac
9
P+

Zodiac

89Trust
2007·2h 37mmovie
CrimeMystery
Gone Baby Gone
10
P+

Gone Baby Gone

89Trust
2007·1h 49mmovie
CrimeDramaMystery
Minority Report
11
PrimeP+

Minority Report

89Trust
2002·2h 19mmoviePG-13
ActionCrimeMystery
Twin Peaks
12
P+

Twin Peaks

88Trust
1990·3 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Yellowjackets
13
NPrimeP+

Yellowjackets

87Trust
2021·4 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaHorrorMystery
Sleepy Hollow
14
Leaving Nov 1
P+

Sleepy Hollow

87Trust
1999·1h 45mmovie
FantasyHorrorMystery
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
15
HuluP+

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation

86Trust
2000·15 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
The Good Wife
16
P+

The Good Wife

86Trust
2009·7 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Basic Instinct
17
P+

Basic Instinct

86Trust
1992·2h 3mmovie
Mystery
The Ring
18
Leaving Nov 1
NPeacockP+

The Ring

86Trust
2002·1h 55mmoviePG-13
HorrorMystery
The Firm
19
Leaving Nov 1
MaxPeacockP+

The Firm

85Trust
1993·2h 28mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Vanilla Sky
20
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Vanilla Sky

85Trust
2001·2h 16mmovieR
FantasyMysteryRomance
Blue Bloods
21
PrimeP+

Blue Bloods

84Trust
2010·14 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Jericho
22
P+

Jericho

84Trust
2006·2 seasonstv
ActionDramaMystery
Disturbia
23
Leaving Nov 1
P+

Disturbia

84Trust
2007·1h 44mmovie
CrimeDramaMystery
Smile 2
24
NP+

Smile 2

83Trust
2024·2h 7mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Kiss the Girls
25
Leaving Nov 1
P+

Kiss the Girls

83Trust
1997·1h 55mmovie
CrimeMystery
Scream VI
26
NP+

Scream VI

83Trust
2023·2h 2mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Smile
27
P+

Smile

83Trust
2022·1h 50mmovie
HorrorMysteryThriller
Star Trek: Generations
28
P+

Star Trek: Generations

83Trust
1994·1h 58mmovie
ActionAdventureMystery
The Faculty
29
P+

The Faculty

83Trust
1998·1h 39mmovie
HorrorMysteryScience Fiction
Scream 2
30
Leaving Nov 1
HuluPeacockP+

Scream 2

82Trust
1997·1h 55mmovieR
HorrorMystery
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
31
P+

Star Trek: The Motion Picture

82Trust
1979·2h 11mmovie
AdventureMysteryScience Fiction
School Spirits
32
P+

School Spirits

81Trust
2023·4 seasonstv
DramaFantasyMystery
Confess, Fletch
33
Leaving Oct 26
P+

Confess, Fletch

81Trust
2022·1h 38mmovie
ComedyCrimeMystery
Scream 4
34
P+

Scream 4

81Trust
2011·1h 51mmovie
HorrorMystery
Paranormal Activity
35
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Paranormal Activity

81Trust
2009·1h 26mmovieR
HorrorMystery
Friday the 13th Part 2
36
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Friday the 13th Part 2

80Trust
1981·1h 27mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Paranormal Activity 3
37
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Paranormal Activity 3

78Trust
2011·1h 24mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Walking Out
38
P+

Walking Out

78Trust
2017·1h 35mmovie
AdventureDramaMystery
Paranormal Activity 2
39
Leaving Nov 1
PeacockP+

Paranormal Activity 2

78Trust
2010·1h 31mmovieR
HorrorMystery
Scream 3
40
Leaving Nov 1
HuluPeacockP+

Scream 3

78Trust
2000·1h 56mmovieR
HorrorMystery

Showing 40 of 47