🍿 Watch Picker
Watchlist

Best on HBO Max / Mystery

The best mystery shows and movies on HBO Max

The highest-rated mystery titles streaming on HBO Max right now, ranked by Trust Score.

Your services:
NHuluPrimeD+TV+MaxPeacock
True Detective
1
Max

True Detective

94Trust
2014·4 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Usual Suspects
2
PrimeMax

The Usual Suspects

93Trust
1995·1h 41mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Mare of Easttown
3
Max

Mare of Easttown

90Trust
2021·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Big Little Lies
4
Max

Big Little Lies

89Trust
2017·2 seasonstvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Night Of
5
Max

The Night Of

88Trust
2016·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
Lanterns
6
Max

Lanterns

87Trust
2026·1 seasontvTV-MA
ActionCrimeMystery
Luther
7
HuluMax

Luther

87Trust
2010·5 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
Sharp Objects
8
Max

Sharp Objects

87Trust
2018·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The White Lotus
9
Max

The White Lotus

87Trust
2021·3 seasonstvTV-MA
ComedyDramaMystery
True Blood
10
HuluMax

True Blood

87Trust
2008·7 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaFantasyMystery
Watchmen
11
Max

Watchmen

87Trust
2019·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Leftovers
12
Max

The Leftovers

86Trust
2014·3 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaFantasyMystery
Infernal Affairs
13
Max

Infernal Affairs

86Trust
2002·1h 40mmovieR
CrimeDramaMystery
Eyes Wide Shut
14
Max

Eyes Wide Shut

85Trust
1999·2h 32mmovieR
DramaMysteryThriller
The Conjuring
15
Max

The Conjuring

85Trust
2013·1h 51mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Weapons
16
Max

Weapons

84Trust
2025·2h 8mmovieR
HorrorMystery
Pretty Little Liars
17
HuluMax

Pretty Little Liars

83Trust
2010·7 seasonstvTV-14
DramaMysteryRomance
Hereditary
18
Max

Hereditary

83Trust
2018·2h 7mmovieR
HorrorMystery
The Conjuring 2
19
Max

The Conjuring 2

83Trust
2016·2h 13mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Bring Her Back
20
Max

Bring Her Back

83Trust
2025·1h 44mmovieR
HorrorMystery
Midsommar
21
Max

Midsommar

83Trust
2019·2h 27mmovieR
DramaHorrorMystery
Carnivàle
22
Max

Carnivàle

81Trust
2003·2 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaFantasyMystery
DTF St. Louis
23
Max

DTF St. Louis

81Trust
2026·1 seasontvTV-MA
ComedyDramaMystery
MythBusters
24
HuluD+Max

MythBusters

81Trust
2003·16 seasonstvTV-PG
DocumentaryMysteryReality
Strike
25
Max

Strike

81Trust
2017·6 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
X
26
HuluMax

X

78Trust
2022·1h 46mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It
27
Max

The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It

77Trust
2021·1h 51mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
The Conjuring: Last Rites
28
Max

The Conjuring: Last Rites

76Trust
2025·2h 15mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Silent Witness
29
Max

Silent Witness

75Trust
1996·29 seasonstvTV-14
CrimeDramaMystery
I, Jack Wright
30
Max

I, Jack Wright

74Trust
2025·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeDramaMystery
The Ex-Wife
31
Max

The Ex-Wife

71Trust
2022·2 seasonstvTV-MA
DramaMysteryThriller
Insidious: The Last Key
32
Max

Insidious: The Last Key

71Trust
2018·1h 43mmoviePG-13
HorrorMysteryThriller
Insidious: The Red Door
33
HuluMax

Insidious: The Red Door

71Trust
2023·1h 42mmoviePG-13
HorrorMysteryThriller
Expedition X
34
Max

Expedition X

68Trust
2020·12 seasonstvTV-PG
MysteryReality
The Nun
35
Max

The Nun

68Trust
2018·1h 36mmovieR
HorrorMysteryThriller
Passenger
36
Max

Passenger

66Trust
2024·1 seasontvTV-MA
CrimeMystery