Watch Picker
For YouMust-Watch TVMust-Watch MoviesNew ReleasesRecently AddedLeaving SoonWatch Party
WatchlistFriendsSign inSign up
Watchlist
Give us Feedback!→
Watch Picker
Best on:
NetflixHuluPrime VideoDisney+Apple TV+HBO MaxPeacockParamount+
New on:
NetflixHuluPrime VideoDisney+Apple TV+HBO MaxPeacockParamount+

Metadata provided by TheTVDB.

Follow us on XPrivacyTermsHow scores workAbout & CreditsStreaming availability for the US© 2026 Watch Picker LLC
A Toxic Love Story

A Toxic Love Story

2026·1h 30mmovieTV-MA
CrimeDocumentary

A sinister Craigslist catfish scheme unfolds between a US marshal, his new wife and his former girlfriend in this twisted true-crime documentary.

Directed by Alexandra Lacey

Starring Amanda Wear, Gavin Marck, Katia Plotnikoff, Lainey Baldwin

Watch on

Watch on Netflix↗

Community Ratings and Reviews

No ratings yet0 ratings · 0 reviews

Sign in to leave a review.

Loading reviews…

More like A Toxic Love Story

The Imposter
Prime

The Imposter

88Trust
2012·1h 38mmovieR
CrimeDocumentary
The Crash
N

The Crash

83Trust
2026·1h 34mmovieTV-MA
CrimeDocumentary
The Widower: 'Til Death Do Us Part
N

The Widower: 'Til Death Do Us Part

83Trust
2026·1h 31mmovieTV-MA
CrimeDocumentary
The Invisible War
Prime

The Invisible War

88Trust
2012·1h 37mmovie
CrimeDocumentary
Drugs, Inc.: Dealer Pov
D+

Drugs, Inc.: Dealer Pov

72Trust
2014·0h 44mmovie
CrimeDocumentary
American Murder: The Family Next Door
N

American Murder: The Family Next Door

87Trust
2020·1h 23mmovieTV-MA
CrimeDocumentary
Maternal Instinct
N

Maternal Instinct

87Trust
2026·1h 36mmovieTV-MA
CrimeDocumentary
Narco Cultura
Prime

Narco Cultura

86Trust
2013·1h 42mmovieR
CrimeDocumentary
The Perfect Neighbor
N

The Perfect Neighbor

86Trust
2025·1h 38mmovieR
CrimeDocumentary
Collective
Prime

Collective

85Trust
2019·1h 49mmovie
CrimeDocumentary